Back

The Times - 7th March 2001 - "Djamileh" - Robert Thicknesse (Review of performance on 1st March in the Linbury Studio Theatre, the Royal Opera House, London)

This is a one-act curiosity composed by Bizet three years before Carmen, inevitably overshadowed by it but in many ways a dry run.

The story, an Arabian Nights by-product from the poem Namouna by Musset, concerns one Haroun, a sex addict from Cairo who is in the habit of acquiring a new slave-girl concubine each month, and Djamileh, the discarded lover who succeeds in domesticating him.

That’s it, really; its attraction for Bizet clearly lay more in the creation of Eastern-flavoured atmosphere through harmonic and rhythmic exotica, and a particularly translucent orchestration, than any dramatic interest.

It was performed by Les Azuriales Opera, an English organisation which provides operas for those unavoidably detained on Cap Ferrat during Glyndebourne. Much of the score’s magic was inevitably lost in the piano accompaniment, which reduced much of the music to a weird blend of Chopin and Sullivan.

Despite this it was a good-natured show, particularly beautifully designed and costumed by Justin Way, Christopher Drake and Dulcie Best, and the proceeds (top tickets cost a healthy £100) went entirely to CHASE Children’s Hospice Service.

The leads were adequately sung by Dewi Wyn and Georgia Ellis-Filice, though neither exuded the necessary sex appeal to raise interest in the story.

Philip Salmon was an engaging presence as Haroun’s servant Splendiano, a buffo character whose operetta tunes contrast with Djamileh’s intense, oriental music and Haroun’s Gounod-like lyricism. This mixing of styles is an obvious precursor of Carmen, less integrated but always easy on the ear.

A lengthy interlude allowed a troupe of generously built dancers from the Josephine Wise Academy of Arabic Dance to undulate with varying degrees of success to a rather nice accompaniment of bagpipe-style drones, sexist chorus and a serpentine melody (originally for woodwind).

Although one suspects that this formula may work better on maquis-scented Riviera nights it still provided a pretty evening’s entertainment in sleety London, and it’s rare enough to see such a well-heeled crowd in the Linbury.

It would be even better if someone was inspired to produce a full performance of the opera: Bizet could not write a dull note, and Djamileh is a pleasant halfway house between the by-the-yard exoticism of The Pearl Fishers and the Grand Guignol of Carmen.

The Evening Standard - 2nd March 2001 - "Slave to Love" - Tom Sutcliffe (Review of Djamileh performance on 1st March in the Linbury Studio Theatre, the Royal Opera House, London)

BIZET paved the way for Carmen with the one-act gem, Djamileh, about a rich Cairo philanderer, Haroun, who changes his favourite female slave monthly.  The current girl has fallen for him, and breaks the cycle by auditioning, veiled, to be her own replacement.  Full of Arab atmosphere, Djamileh is a revealing topic in an age of divorces – when new partners so often fit the pattern of old.  It’s also a neat length for the dinner-plus-opera recipe at Villa Ephrussi in Cap Ferrat, an Edwardian Rothschild palace that is home to the opera festival Les Azuriales.

This production was performed at the Linbury with the Royal Opera’s studio space rearranged in the round making the intimate opera more confessional.  There was a certain hypnotic fascination in the rippling belly muscles of dancing slave-girls, encouraging bankers’ and lawyers’ charity towards Chase Children’s Hospice Serce.  Justin Way’s staging told the story simply and effectively, though three sprinklings of tinsel from the roof seemed excessive.  And the piano accompaniment couldn’t do justice to one of Bizet’s most finely coloured orchestral scores.  Dewi Wyn was handsome and appealing as the Pasha, while not quite possessing lyrical beauty and singing elegance.  Philip Salmon as his urbane tutor Splendiano, hungry for Djamileh but not resentful when rejected, sounded velvety and benign.  In the title role, Georgia Ellis-Filice sang gorgeously and was convincingly romantic.  The work’s ambivalence needed more sensitive exploration.

(Classified by the Evening Standard as "Good")

Back